Head-to-Head: MobX vs Redux Analysis

mobx

v6.13.5(about 1 month ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 0Monthly npm downloads

MobX is a simple, scalable state management library for JavaScript applications. It enables developers to create reactive data models that automatically update when the underlying data changes. MobX follows a more direct and transparent approach compared to other state management solutions like Redux, reducing boilerplate code and making it easier to maintain and understand the application's state.

Alternatives: redux, recoil, easy-peasy

Tags: javascriptstate-managementreactivedata-modelsscalable

redux

v5.0.1(11 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 0Monthly npm downloads

Redux is a predictable state container for JavaScript apps, commonly used with libraries like React or Angular for managing application state. It provides a centralized store to manage the entire state of an application, making it easier to track changes and maintain consistency across components. Redux follows a unidirectional data flow pattern, enhancing predictability and traceability of state changes.

Alternatives:

mobx+
zustand+
recoil+
flux+
effector+
easy-peasy+
valtio+
jotai+
pullstate+
overmind+

Tags: javascriptstate-managementpredictable-state-containerunidirectional-data-flow

Fight!

State Management Approach

MobX is more focused on simplicity and ease of use. It uses observables to track state changes and automatically updates components that depend on those observables. Redux, on the other hand, follows a more strict and structured approach with actions, reducers, and a single immutable store.

Developer Experience

MobX is often considered easier to learn and use due to its simpler concepts and less boilerplate code. Redux, while more verbose, provides a clear separation of concerns and a predictable state management flow, which can be beneficial for larger applications.

Performance

In terms of performance, MobX is known for its reactivity system that efficiently updates components when the state changes. Redux, with its immutable state and unidirectional data flow, can sometimes lead to unnecessary re-renders, but this can be optimized using techniques like memoization.

Scalability

Redux's strict structure and immutability make it more suitable for larger applications where predictability and maintainability are crucial. MobX, with its more flexible and dynamic nature, might require additional discipline to maintain scalability in larger codebases.

Community and Ecosystem

Redux has a larger community and ecosystem with a wide range of middleware, tools, and extensions available. MobX has a smaller but dedicated community and a simpler ecosystem, which can be advantageous for developers looking for a more straightforward solution.

Learning Curve

MobX is often considered easier for beginners due to its simpler concepts and less boilerplate code. Redux, with its strict structure and concepts like actions and reducers, might have a steeper learning curve, especially for developers new to state management.